There’s something special about a freshly made donut. A golden, fluffy center, a sweet glaze, and that first bite while it’s still fresh. Whether you’re a fan of classic vanilla, rich chocolate, or seasonal maple, homemade donuts are a delicious treat worth making from scratch.
But what if you could make your favorite bakery-style donuts while supporting certified organic farmers and food producers? With a little patience and a handful of carefully sourced organic ingredients, you can!
We’re making traditional yeast-raised organic donuts with three irresistible glazes: classic vanilla, chocolate, and maple. Along the way, I’ll introduce you to some of the CCOF-certified producers behind the ingredients.
And yes, they’re fried. Some treats are simply meant to be enjoyed!
Why Make Donuts with Organic Ingredients?
Choosing organic isn’t just for salads and smoothies. Your favorite desserts are another opportunity to support the farmers and food producers working to protect our soil, water, and local communities. Certified organic ingredients are produced and handled according to rigorous USDA organic standards, with independent inspections and oversight.
When you choose certified organic flour, milk, eggs, sugar, and other baking ingredients, you’re supporting a food system built around those standards. Homemade baking gives you another advantage: you get to choose exactly which ingredients go into your food. For this recipe, I sourced ingredients from nine CCOF-certified organic businesses, many offering products that consumers can purchase online or at grocery stores. I purchased everything either directly from the producer, through Amazon/Whole Foods grocery delivery, or from my local grocery store.
Find CCOF-certified organic ingredients near you in our CCOF Member Directory.
Homemade Organic Yeast-Raised Donuts
Yield: Approximately 24 small donuts, depending on cutter size.
Prep and rising time: Approximately 2-3 hours
Cooking time: Approximately 20-30 minutes
Total time: Approximately 3-3½ hours
Ingredients
- 4¼ cups (510 g) organic all-purpose flour (Farm2Flour | CCOF Directory)
- 1¼ cups (300 mL) organic grass-fed whole milk (Alexandre Family Farm | CCOF Directory)
- 2¼ teaspoons organic instant yeast (Red Star Organic)
- 2 large organic eggs (Chino Valley Ranchers | CCOF Directory)
- 8 tablespoons (113 g) organic lightly salted butter, melted and cooled (Straus Family Creamery | CCOF Directory)
- ¼ cup (50 g) organic cane sugar (McCabe Organic | CCOF Directory)
- ¾ teaspoon fine salt
- ½ teaspoon organic vanilla powder (Cook Flavoring Company | CCOF Directory)
- ¼ teaspoon organic ground nutmeg (Whole Spice | CCOF Directory)
- Organic high-oleic sunflower oil, approximately 2 quarts or enough for safe frying depth (La Tourangelle | CCOF Directory)
A note about certification: The organic yeast in this recipe is certified by another USDA-accredited organic certifier, rather than CCOF. Salt is a naturally occurring mineral and is not eligible for organic certification. The agricultural ingredients were selected from certified organic products, with CCOF-certified businesses featured throughout.
Instructions
Step 1: Prepare the dough
Warm the milk to approximately 95-100°F. The milk should be comfortably warm, not hot.
In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the milk, eggs, melted butter, sugar, yeast, and vanilla powder.
Add the flour, salt, and nutmeg. Mix until combined and no dry flour remains.
Step 2: Let the flour hydrate
Cover the dough and allow it to rest for 25 minutes, giving the flour time to hydrate.
*This step is particularly helpful when working with freshly stone-milled flour, which can absorb moisture differently from conventional flour. Farm2Flour is freshly milled from heritage wheat and usually shipped within a few days of milling. This rest allows the flour to absorb liquid before kneading, making it easier to assess the dough’s consistency.
Step 3: Knead the dough
Knead for approximately 6-10 minutes, until the dough becomes smooth, elastic, and slightly tacky.
The dough should be soft but manageable. If it remains excessively sticky after kneading, add flour in small increments, approximately 1 tablespoon at a time.
Step 4: First rise
Transfer the dough to a bowl and cover.
Let rise in a warm location for approximately 1-1½ hours, or until doubled in size.
Step 5: Cut the donuts
Turn the risen dough onto a lightly floured surface.
Gently roll to approximately ½-inch thickness.
Use a 2½- to 3-inch donut cutter to cut the donuts, then a smaller cutter to remove the centers.
*Don’t have a donut cutter? A wide-mouth mason jar lid and a small round glass or cutter work beautifully!
Place the donuts (and donut holes if making those too) on a parchment or silicone baking mat-lined baking sheet, leaving room between them.
Step 6: Second rise
Cover loosely and let rise for approximately 30-45 minutes, until the donuts look noticeably puffy.
Step 7: Fry the donuts
Heat the organic sunflower oil in a deep, heavy-bottomed pot to approximately 330-350°F.
Carefully lower a few donuts into the oil without crowding the pot.
Fry until golden brown and cooked through, approximately 30-60 seconds per side, adjusting for fluctuations in oil temperature. Smaller donut holes will cook more quickly.
*Tip: Use a pair of chopsticks to check and flip the donuts. Way easier than the big spoon!
Transfer to a wire rack to drain and cool.
Three Homemade Organic Donut Glazes
The best part of this recipe? One batch of donuts, three delicious flavors! Each glaze uses organic ingredients, including a homemade powdered sugar base.
Make Your Own Organic Powdered Sugar
You don’t need to purchase a separate bag of powdered sugar to make these glazes.
Simply add organic cane sugar (McCabe Organic | CCOF Directory) to a high-powered blender or coffee grinder and blend until it becomes a fine powder. Allow the sugar dust to settle before opening the blender, then sift to remove any remaining coarse crystals (optional: I skipped this step).
*Kitchen tip: Prepare approximately 540 g of finely powdered organic cane sugar for all three glazes. Homemade powdered sugar contains no added anti-caking starch, so the finished glazes may behave slightly differently from those made with commercial confectioners’ sugar.
Classic Organic Vanilla Glaze
Sweet, delicate, and timeless, this is the classic glazed donut everyone knows and loves.
Ingredients
- 180 g homemade organic powdered sugar (McCabe Organic | CCOF Directory)
- 1½-2 tablespoons organic whole milk (Alexandre Family Farm | CCOF Directory)
- ½ teaspoon organic vanilla powder (Cook Flavoring Company | CCOF Directory)
- Pinch of salt
Instructions
- Sift the powdered sugar into a mixing bowl.
- Add the vanilla powder, salt, and 1½ tablespoons milk.
- Whisk until smooth and glossy.
- Add additional milk by the teaspoon until the glaze is thick but dippable.
- Dip and twist the tops of cooled donuts and return them to the wire rack to set.
Organic Maple-Glazed Donuts
For all the fall lovers! This glaze was bursting with maple flavor!
Ingredients
- 180 g homemade organic powdered sugar (McCabe Organic | CCOF Directory)
- 1-2 tablespoons organic whole milk (Alexandre Family Farm | CCOF Directory)
- 1 teaspoon organic pure maple extract, or to taste (Cook Flavoring Company | CCOF Directory)
- Pinch of salt
Instructions
- Sift the powdered sugar into a mixing bowl.
- Add the maple extract, salt, and 1 tablespoon milk.
- Whisk until smooth.
- Taste and adjust the maple flavor as desired.
- Add more milk by the teaspoon until the glaze reaches a thick, dippable consistency.
- Dip and twist cooled donuts and allow the glaze to set.
Kitchen tip: Pure organic maple extract delivers concentrated maple flavor without adding extra liquid from maple syrup, helping the glaze maintain its consistency.
Organic Chocolate-Frosted Donuts
For chocolate lovers, this sweet, rich frosting combines real organic dark chocolate with a classic powdered sugar icing.
Ingredients
- 3 ounces (85 g) organic 66% dark baking chocolate (TCHO Sweet & Sassy | CCOF Directory)
- 180 g homemade organic powdered sugar (McCabe Organic | CCOF Directory)
- ¼ cup heavy whipping cream (Straus Family Creamery cream | CCOF Directory)
- 2 tablespoons organic lightly salted butter (Straus Family Creamery | CCOF Directory)
- ¼ teaspoon organic vanilla powder Cook Flavoring Company | CCOF Directory)
Instructions
- Roughly chop the chocolate.
- Heat the cream and butter together over low heat until the butter melts and the mixture is hot and steaming. DO NOT LET IT BOIL!
- Add the chocolate and whisk until it is completely melted and smooth.
- Gradually whisk in the sifted powdered sugar and vanilla powder.
- If the frosting is too thick or chunky, add a bit of milk.
- Dip and twist cooled donuts into the frosting and allow them to set on a wire rack.
Glazing tip for all three flavors: Keep your glazes slightly warm, but not hot, while working. If they begin to thicken or crystallize before you’ve finished dipping, briefly set the bowl over warm water and stir until smooth. Glazing fully cooled donuts helps prevent the frosting from soaking into the dough.
Meet the Certified Organic Producers Behind This Recipe
One of the joys of making food from scratch is discovering where your ingredients come from. For this recipe, we selected ingredients from nine CCOF-certified organic businesses, including farms, dairies, mills, and specialty food makers across the United States.
Farm2Flour: Keeping Farming in the Family
Four generations of farming meet a fresh approach to flour at Farm2Flour in Illinois. With a commitment to organic growing practices, healthy soil, and heritage grains, this family farm brings consumers closer to the source of their food. Their wheat is traditionally stone-milled just one day before shipping, preserving the character and freshness of every harvest.
McCabe Organic: Making Organic an Everyday Choice
Founded on the belief that wholesome food should be accessible to everyone, McCabe Organic has spent more than a decade connecting consumers with organic pantry staples. From grains and beans to flours and sweeteners, this California-based business combines traditional food knowledge with a commitment to organic agriculture, making it easier to bring organic ingredients into everyday kitchens.
Alexandre Family Farm: Healthy Soil, Happy Cows
On California’s northern coast, the Alexandre family believes healthy food begins beneath our feet. Their regenerative approach to organic dairy farming centers on living soil, thriving pastures, and animals grazing in harmony with the land. Now spanning multiple generations, the family is working to preserve a farming legacy that nourishes both people and the ecosystems they depend on.
Chino Valley Ranchers: A Legacy of Caring for Hens
What began as a family egg business in 1952 has grown into three generations of innovation in organic egg production. Chino Valley Ranchers was an early advocate for cage-free hens and organic farming. The family even operates its own certified organic poultry feed mill, reflecting a commitment to knowing exactly what goes into caring for their flocks.
Straus Family Creamery: Pioneers with a Purpose
When Albert Straus founded the nation’s first 100% certified organic creamery in 1994, he helped change the future of American dairy farming. Today, Straus continues that pioneering spirit by supporting local family dairies and investing in climate-smart agriculture. From renewable energy generated by cow manure to preserving farmland, their commitment extends far beyond the creamery.
TCHO: Chocolate That Starts with Farmers
Great chocolate begins long before the first bite. Through its TCHO (pronounced “choh”) Source program, this California chocolate maker works directly with cacao-growing communities to improve quality and strengthen producer partnerships. Its innovative Flavor Labs even allow farmers to make and taste chocolate from their own cacao, giving growers a greater role in shaping the final product.
La Tourangelle: Tradition Meets Innovation
Rooted in generations of French artisan oil-making, La Tourangelle brings traditional craftsmanship to its California mill. The family-owned company combines careful sourcing and pressing methods with a commitment to environmental stewardship. Its Woodland facility incorporates solar energy, while the La Tourangelle Foundation supports food and gardening education for local schoolchildren.
Cook Flavoring Company: A Century of Flavor
For more than 100 years, the Lochhead family has dedicated itself to the art of vanilla. Now in its fourth generation, Cook Flavoring Company continues using the slow, cold extraction methods developed by its founder in 1918. The family also works directly with vanilla-growing communities around the world, preserving craftsmanship while building meaningful relationships from bean to bottle.
Whole Spice: A World of Flavor, Rooted in Family
Whole Spice began with Shuli and Ronit’s shared love of the culinary traditions they inherited from their families in Yemen and Morocco. What started at Bay Area farmers markets in 2000 grew into a beloved California spice business. Their commitment to freshly ground spices, authentic flavors, and organic options keeps those traditions alive while bringing global flavors into American kitchens.
Choosing an Organic Frying Oil: A Word on Seed Oils
Seed oils have become a hot topic in conversations about food and health. Concerns range from omega-6 fatty acids and inflammation to industrial processing, repeated high-temperature frying, and the prevalence of refined oils in ultra-processed foods. These are important conversations, but one distinction often gets lost: not all seed oils have the same composition, and how they’re produced matters.
For our donuts, I intentionally selected La Tourangelle’s Organic High Oleic Sunflower Oil, an expeller-pressed oil certified organic by CCOF. Here’s what makes it different.
A Different Kind of Sunflower Oil
Oleic acid is a monounsaturated fatty acid found abundantly in olive and avocado oils. According to international Codex standards, high-oleic sunflower oil contains at least 75% oleic acid, giving it a fatty-acid profile similar to those familiar cooking oils. Traditional sunflower oil, by contrast, contains considerably more linoleic acid, an omega-6 polyunsaturated fat.
Omega-6 fatty acids are essential nutrients, but their relationship with inflammation has generated considerable debate. While some inflammatory signaling molecules are derived from omega-6 fats, a systematic review of randomized clinical trials did not find a consistent overall increase in inflammatory markers with higher linoleic acid intake.
For consumers who prefer to limit omega-6 intake, however, high-oleic sunflower oil offers a meaningful distinction: substantially less omega-6 linoleic acid than traditional sunflower oil.
Why Does That Matter for Cooking?
Fatty-acid composition influences how an oil behaves when heated. Polyunsaturated fats are generally more susceptible to oxidation than monounsaturated fats, particularly during prolonged or repeated high-temperature cooking.
As oils oxidize, they can form degradation compounds. A 2025 study of sunflower oils used for frying found that high-oleic sunflower oil resisted deterioration better than traditional sunflower oil, supporting its suitability for frying.
Its neutral flavor also lets the organic ingredients in our donuts shine.
How It’s Made Matters
Part of the seed-oil conversation reflects a broader concern about industrial food processing. Refined vegetable oils are common ingredients in ultra-processed foods, and NIH research has linked ultra-processed diets to overeating. But the effects of an entire dietary pattern cannot necessarily be attributed to one ingredient alone.
Oil production methods also vary. Some conventional vegetable oils are extracted using industrial solvents such as hexane. Expeller pressing instead uses mechanical pressure to extract oil from seeds.
La Tourangelle’s organic sunflower oil is expeller-pressed, and its CCOF certification verifies compliance with USDA organic handling standards, which prohibit unapproved volatile synthetic solvents such as hexane in organic processing.
These are meaningful differences in how an ingredient is produced. Organic certification does not guarantee specific health outcomes, but it offers independent verification of agricultural and processing practices, giving consumers greater confidence in the choices they make.
Our decision to use this oil was intentional: its fatty-acid composition, frying performance, mechanical extraction, and organic certification all played a role.
Prefer to Avoid Seed Oils? We Have an Organic Option for That Too!
If avocado oil is more your style, Marianne’s Harvest Organic Avocado Oil is another excellent choice. Produced by fifth-generation family business Adams Group and certified organic by CCOF, this pure avocado oil offers a neutral flavor and a manufacturer-reported smoke point of up to 500°F, making it another option for homemade donuts.
There is no single cooking oil that meets everyone’s needs or preferences, and that’s okay. Whether you choose sunflower or avocado oil, understanding what goes into your food, how it’s produced, and the people behind it empowers you to make choices that reflect your values.
That’s the heart of choosing organic: knowing more about your food and the people who produce it so you can make informed decisions with your purchasing power.
How to Find Certified Organic Ingredients
Look for the USDA Organic seal and the certifying organization’s name on the product packaging.
USDA Organic standards are established and overseen by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, while accredited certification organizations such as CCOF verify that certified operations meet those requirements.
Many certified producers also sell directly to consumers through their websites or online markets, making it easier than ever to discover organic ingredients beyond the grocery store.
Find all these farms and more in the CCOF Organic Directory.
Search for specific crops, ingredients, producers, or locations to explore certified organic farms and businesses across the country.
Whether you’re searching for flour, dairy, produce, or pantry staples, the directory helps connect you with the people and businesses behind certified organic products.
A Sweet Way to Support Organic
Homemade donuts take a little more time than picking up a box from the bakery, but there’s something rewarding about creating a special treat from scratch.
And when you choose certified organic ingredients, you’re doing more than making something delicious. You’re supporting the farmers and food producers who help make organic agriculture possible.
Whether you choose classic vanilla, chocolate, or maple, I hope these homemade organic donuts bring a little sweetness to your kitchen. They certainly did for me! I gave myself a sugar-high while frying as I couldn’t keep from eating the glazes!
Looking for more cooking inspiration? Explore our organic recipes and discover new ways to make organic part of your everyday life.
Recipe adapted from the yeast-raised doughnut formula by Mark Bittman, published in The New York Times Cooking, with organic ingredient substitutions, an additional flour hydration rest, and three glaze variations.